Pick Your Poison Glass Cup
Pick Your Poison Glass Cup
Pick Your Poison Glass Cup
Pick Your Poison Glass Cup
Pick Your Poison Glass Cup
Pick Your Poison Glass Cup
Pick Your Poison Glass Cup
BEST SELLER 6 / 7

“Even prettier in person, and I have worn them every day since they arrived.”

5.0Maya R.

4.9/5 from 600+ happy besties

Pick Your Poison Glass Cup

Your Halloween drinkware does not need to be sweet to be fun. Pick Your Poison is for the spooky-season regular who prefers potion bottles, poison apples, purple smoke, and a little theatrical menace with her morning coffee.

The lime-green lettering, purple gothic frame, skulls, spiders, bats, and labeled potion bottles make this a full-scene design for the person who starts decorating before October arrives. Whether it holds cold brew, a Halloween cocktail, or your usual iced tea, it belongs in the rotation all season long.

  • Detailed witchy Halloween artwork with potion bottles, skulls, spiders, bats, cobwebs, and a poison apple
  • “Pick Your Poison” message delivers the right amount of spooky attitude for coffee, cocktails, or mocktails
  • Purple, green, and black gothic color palette stands out against the usual orange Halloween cups
  • A strong Halloween gift for witches, horror lovers, goth fans, emos, and the friend with year-round spooky décor
  • Handmade UVDTF design, made in Virginia

Care note: Hand wash only. Do not soak or put in the dishwasher.

$32.00
  • Easy & Free 30-Day Returns
  • 150+ Happy Besties
Choose Your Size Size guide

  • 30-Day Money Back Guarantee

  • Secure & Encrypted Checkout

What's in the bag?

A padded collar and a cushioned footbed on a rubber sole with a light tread. The upper is a soft, breathable mix that keeps its shape, with a wide toe box and a lace-up front that stays tied.

Shipping + Delivery

Orders are handmade, made to order, and ship from Virginia. Most orders process in 7-10 business days, with standard delivery taking 3–5 business days after shipment.

Returns + Exchanges

Returns are accepted on non-personalized, unused items within 30 days of delivery. Items damaged in transit or defective will be replaced or refunded. Full details are available in our Policies.

Care instructions

Wipe with a damp cloth and a little soap, then let them dry away from heat. Machine washing softens the glue, so it is worth the two minutes by hand.

Free shipping

On orders over $75

30-day money back

Love them or get your money back

Secure checkout

Encrypted and safe payments

Premium quality

Made to last, guaranteed